| 2022 |
Orlando City SC |
| 2019 |
Atlanta United FC |
| 2017 |
Sporting Kansas City |
| 2016 |
FC Dallas |
| 2015 |
Sporting Kansas City |
| 2014 |
Seattle Sounders FC |
| 2011 |
Seattle Sounders FC |
| 2009 |
Seattle Sounders FC |
| 2008 |
D.C. United |
| 2007 |
New England Revolution |
| 2002 |
Columbus Crew |
| 1999 |
Rochester Rhinos |
| 1996 |
D.C. United |
| 1995 |
Richmond Kickers |
| 1994 |
Greek-American A.C. |
| 1992 |
San Jose Oaks |
| 1991 |
Brooklyn Italians |
| 1990 |
A.A.C. Eagles |
| 1989 |
St. Petersburg Kickers |
| 1988 |
St. Louis Busch Seniors |
| 1987 |
Club España |
| 1986 |
St. Louis Kutis S.C. |
| 1985 |
Greek-American A.C. |
| 1984 |
New York AO Krete |
| 1983 |
New York Pancyprian-Freedoms |
| 1982 |
New York Pancyprian-Freedoms |
| 1981 |
Maccabi Los Angeles |
| 1980 |
New York Pancyprian-Freedoms |
| 1978 |
Maccabi Los Angeles |
| 1977 |
Maccabi Los Angeles |
| 1975 |
Maccabi Los Angeles |
| 1973 |
Maccabi Los Angeles |
| 1972 |
Elizabeth S.C. |
| 1970 |
Elizabeth S.C. |
| 1965 |
Ukrainian Sports Club NY |
| 1964 |
Los Angeles Kickers |
| 1962 |
New York Hungaria |
| 1958 |
Los Angeles Kickers |
| 1957 |
St. Louis Kutis S.C. |
| 1956 |
Harmarville Hurricanes |
| 1955 |
S.C. Eintracht |
| 1954 |
New York Americans |
| 1953 |
Chicago Falcons |
| 1952 |
Harmarville Hurricanes |
| 1950 |
St. Louis Simpkins-Ford |
| 1949 |
Morgan Strasser |
| 1948 |
St. Louis Simpkins-Ford |
| 1947 |
Ponta Delgada S.C. |
| 1945 |
Brookhattan |
| 1944 |
Brooklyn Hispano |
| 1943 |
Brooklyn Hispano |
| 1938 |
Chicago Sparta |
| 1937 |
New York Americans |
| 1936 |
Uhrik Truckers |
| 1934 |
Stix, Baer and Fuller F.C. |
| 1933 |
Stix, Baer and Fuller F.C. |
| 1932 |
New Bedford Whalers |
| 1931 |
Fall River F.C. |
| 1927 |
Fall River F.C. |
| 1913 |
Brooklyn Field Club |